Skip to content

Country Music’s Top 20 Underdogs (Part 4)

February 22, 2008

5. Sugarland: A band that started off as a minor trio has evolved into country music’s most powerful duo of the day. When the band started out they looked as if they would be a short lived success as they slowly ranked consistent top 10 hits but never scored a #1. They finally missed out on a top 10 with the release of “Down In Mississippi”. At the same time they lost their founding member which put the band at risk of losing their credibility. Despite this, the band was able to make a second album which proved much more successful. The once underestimated duo scored two #1 singles in a row as well as a #2 album beaten only by Keith Urban. However even this wouldn’t stand up to their biggest challenge, the CMA duo of the year award which had been held for years by Brooks & Dunn. Despite this Sugarland managed to gain both the CMA award and a CMT award, beating out the former top duo in the genre to take their place as country’s biggest duo.


4. The Dixie Chicks: The most controversial band in the genre and possibly in music made the ultimate comeback despite their poor standing with country fans. The formulated their lost recent album, “Taking The Long Way”, around their outspoken personalities and the controversy surrounding their career after their tussle with Toby Keith concerning comments towards George Bush. The album seemed as if it would be a flop and all three singles were radio flops, the most successful being “Not Ready To Make Nice”. Despite this the album earned critical support and became a huge #1 album for the trio. Some would say this was only duo to the remaining fans after the band was slaughtered. This proved untrue as the band made a triumphant return with no genre support, no radio support, and seemingly minimal fans support and scored five Grammy nominations for their single and album. They dominated all five categories over all other genres and reclaimed the #1 album spot for six consecutive weeks as well as earning critical support towards Natalee Maines free speech and expression. In addition, the trio earned credibility outside of country radio as “Not Ready To Make Nice” hit the top 5 in the Billboard Hot 100 chart.

3. John Rich: John began in Lonestar in their early years, however he made a risky choice of dropping from the band to pursue more solo opportunities, however their was controversy over the actual specifics of this. He signed with BNA and started a very poor solo career. John joined Big Kenny in the early 2000s to form Big & Rich and make an attempt as a successful songwriter. He became a huge part of what would become the Muzic Mafia and helped bring superstar Gretchen Wilson onto the scene before he and Big Kenny finally made their big break with the popular “Save A Horse (Ride A Cowboy)”, a risky single that crossed all boundaries to usher in a new age in country music. John would also go on to become one of the most well known and respected songwriters as his popularity grew and he sooner or later scored even more credibility as a producer. His most recent efforts have helped his soar over his former group, Lonestar, in success and made him much more than a simple singer. Recently he was able to for his own show giving singer from other genres the opportunity to make a break in country music to continue his impression on the genre.

2. Miranda Lambert: The only Nashville Star contestant to ever really succeed has truly earned her place among country music’s top new artists. After her run in the first season Miranda made an attempt at securing a writing contract. She ended up with more than that by also securing a record deal, however her debut single didn’t fair to well and it looked as if she would fall victim to what would become a long line of failures for Nashville Star alums. Despite her poor chart success, Miranda had secured enough support from Nashville Star to earn a #1 debut album which came out of nowhere in the eyes of those who were not familiar with her appearance on the show. After a second flop single Miranda finally broke through with her huge hit “Kerosene” which put her in good standings in the ears of country fans for her rebellious attitude. When her second album approached, the title track “Crazy Ex-Girlfriend” earned her credit as an excellent performer but not as a radio artist as it continued her line of flops. In the wake of all this, Miranda would earn a nomination and finally a win as the ACM Best New Female Vocalist and a Grammy nomination for what would become her most successful hit to date, “Famous In A Small Town”. Her sophomore album would receive rave reviews from critics and become another #1 album. Despite the fact that radio has rejected her and she hails from a show that has produced many unsuccessful singers, Miranda has used her talent and personality to bring herself to the top of her game.


1. Rodney Atkins: If there ever was an underdog, this would be the guy. Rodney stared recording for Curb Records in 1997 and during that same year experienced a flop single and a debut album that would never be released. In 2002 he attempted to break out again with two more flops. However the next year brought Rodney some decent success with a top 5 hit “Honesty”. Despite the single’s success the album would end very badly, reaching #50 in the album charts. Usually this would spell defeat for an artist as hit next two singles made it look as if Rodney was a one hit wonder. He fell silent until finally in 2006 he released “If You’re Going Through Hell (Before The Devil Even Knows)”, a single that would become Rodney’s first #1 hit and surprise country music fans everywhere. Rodney finally reclaimed the success that his breakthrough hit had promised him. However what makes Rodney the ultimate underdog in the genre is that his success didn’t stop there. Rodney became the golden boy of country music and earned a #1 album. He continued to release three more singles from the album which would all hit #1 very quickly giving Rodney four #1 singles in a row and two, “If You’re Going Through Hell” and “Watching You”, would go on to become the most played country music songs of 2006 and 2007. Rodney’s surprising success would earn him the ACM Top New Male Vocalist award, the only major award for which he has been nominated to date. Rodney has not reached “superstar” status but has become a dominating force on the charts. Rodney used his songwriting, persistence, and general talent to earn his way to where he is from a flop career. He has hid in the shadows for years and has revealed himself in a big way.

8 Comments leave one →
  1. Leeann permalink
    February 23, 2008 5:41 am

    This was an excellent feature!! Well written and well researched. I think you’re absolutely right about Rodney, now that you point it out. It’s really amazing that he’s not a superstar since all four of his songs from his current album have gone #1. He must be kind of frustrated. What’s a guy gotta do to become a superstar in country music anyway?

  2. holly permalink
    February 26, 2008 7:21 pm

    one question, and great feature by the way. do you mean the people who became really successful even though they had a disadvantage, or do you mean the pople who even though they have had a lot of success theya re still not as big of stars as they should be? i love the list. rodney atkins is one of my favorites. i’ve been reading your website a lot and i think it’s really well done and interesting!

  3. cowboybleau permalink*
    February 26, 2008 9:30 pm

    Its actually compiled of both Holly. As you can see Rodney suffered from both while others in the list have suffered from one or the other. It came down to who had the more impressive record and has been very successful despite a poor start, a career setback, or being swept under the rug while other artists recieve more attension that may deserve. I am also a huge fan of Rodney’s and don’t believe he has been given enough credit. In addition tis amaizing that he was a one hit wonder and came back with 4 #1 hits in a row.

  4. Jordan Stacey permalink
    March 2, 2008 5:59 pm

    I was just wondering, What about Jo Dee Messina. After her first two singles she kind of dissapeared. Then she came back with 3 back to back #1’s. Then after “Was That My Life” started faltering at radio they cancelled her album and put out a greatest hits package instead. Meanwhile she was having personal problems. Then she came back again with “My Give A Damn’s Busted”

    I think she should have made the list. Otherwise it’s a really good list.

  5. cowboybleau permalink*
    March 3, 2008 3:44 pm

    I see where you’re coming from Jordan and you are right. There are many underdogs I did miss and I willingly admit Jo Dee was one of them. it was a hard list to come up with, but oh was it fun.

  6. Jordan Stacey permalink
    March 3, 2008 5:12 pm

    Yeah I know there was probably a lot who had to be left off, but when I finished reading the first part I immediatley thought of Jo Dee. Though I do agree with most if not all the selections.
    Keep Up the good work!

  7. October 22, 2008 3:49 pm

    LOVE EM(=

  8. October 31, 2009 1:54 am

    Have any of you ever listened to Jason Brown?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: